Policing the City: Crime and Legal Authority in London, 1780-1840In Policing the City, Harris seeks to explain the transformation of criminal justice, particularly the transformation of policing, between the 1780s and 1830s in the City of London. As utilitarian legal reformers argued that criminal deterrence ought to be based on certain and rational punishment rather than random execution, they also had to control the discretionary authority of enforcement. This meant in theory and practice the centralization of policing in the 1830s, and the end of local policing, which was seen as corrupt, inefficient, and unsuitable for rational criminal justice. Revolutionary changes in policing began locally, however, in the 1780s. Such local changes preceded and inspired national reforms, and local policing up to the centralizing measures of the 1830s remained dynamic, responsive, and locally accountable right until its demise. Anxiety about policing had as much to do with the social origins of the police as it did about the origins of criminality, and control over the discretionary authority of watchmen and constables played a larger role in criminal justice reform than the nature of crime. The national, metropolitan, and City police reforms of the late 1830s were thus the culmination of a contentious argument over the meanings of justice, efficiency, and order, rather than its beginning. Harris's evidence reveals how what we've come to think of as "modern" policing evolved out of local practice and reflects shifts in wider debates about crime, justice, and discretionary authority. |
Contents
The Crisis Decade 17831793 33333 | 38 |
War Revolution and Public Legitimacy 17931815 | 53 |
Ideology Pragmatism and the Reform of City | 87 |
Copyright | |
3 other sections not shown
Other editions - View all
Policing the City: Crime and Legal Authority in London, 1780-1840 Andrew Todd Harris Limited preview - 2004 |
Policing the City: Crime & Legal Authority in London, 1780-1840 Andrew T Harris No preview available - 2021 |
Common terms and phrases
Aldersgate Aldgate appointed attend authority Bartholomew Fair Bishopsgate brothels Castle Baynard centralization citizens City leaders City marshals City of London City Patrole City policing City's Colquhoun committed Common Council Corporation Court of Aldermen Court of Common Day and Night decades duties E. P. Thompson early nineteenth century efficiency eighteenth century employed enforcement England English Criminal Law execution extra constables February February 11 Gatrell hired Ibid increase inhabitants late eighteenth lord mayor magistrates Metropolis Minute Book Misc Night Patrole Books Nightly Watch Committee October officers Old Bailey paid Papers CC parish Parliament parliamentary Patrick Colquhoun persons petition pillory Police Committee police reform present proposed prosecution prostitution public order punishment Radzinowicz Rag Fair regulation Report residents responsibility riots served social substitutes suggests thief-taking thieves tion Treatise University Press vagrants ward constables ward leaders ward policing ward's Wardmote Inquest Watch Act watch-house watchmen